DRAMeXchange : Weekly Research : 【Performance Test】

【Performance Test】SSD Benchmark Comparison: 32 Mainstream SATA 2 and SATA 3 SSD in 2H2011 - Overview


Published 2011-05-30 (GMT+8)
 


 
 

Overview


A solid-state drive (SDD) is a data storage device based on NAND Flash memory. Due to the price decline and the technology improvement of Flash chip, SSD products have become more and more mature and the price has become more affordable for the market and industry, which results in a significant growth in SSD shipment in 2011 and shows that the current technology and cost of SSD have met the market demand.

For most PC and laptop users, SSD is no longer unaffordable or a luxury when pursuing better efficiency. Instead, it has become one of the most adapted ways to improve computer efficiency.

The fast boot SSD brings to various operating systems is very noticeable: it takes merely 6 seconds for Ubuntu Linux and ten seconds or so for Windows 7 to go from BIOS to desktop. It also shortens the start-ups of most application programs and files to less than two seconds.

Moreover, benefiting from the fact that unlike the motor mechanism of traditional hard-disc, the mechanism of SSD is purely physical and electrical, laptops equipped with SSDs are immune to the data loss and hard-disk failure caused by users moving the laptops while the hard-disks are running. Because SSD does not require a magnetic disc or a motor, it is much lighter than a traditional hard-disk. One of the most eminent SSD applications is event data recorders: because of the technology maturity and price decline of SSD, SSD has contributed to the popularization of the event data recorders in the car markets over the recent years and is a much superior choice than traditional hard-disks to be adopted in event date recorders.

 

DRAMeXchange: Annual Review of SSD

In this year's annual review of SSD by DRAMeXchange, a research division of Trendforce, we test out 32 different 2.5-inch SSDs, including standard SSDs with affordable prices and high-speed SDDs, which are adopted by medium and small size companies and work stations, with several categories (SATA2 with 60GB and 100GB storage and SATA3 with over 100GB storage.)

SDDs are categorized based on their communication specifications and storage amounts to distinguish their differences. According to the survey by DRAMeXchange, the speed of data transmission is about 100MB/sec for traditional hard-disks and over 200MB/sec for mainstream SDDs. Due to the limit of its communication specifications, the maximum speed of data transmission of a SATA2 hard-disk is 300MB/sec. It is reasonable to adopt SATA3 model and the latest flash chips when producing a new SSD, which can increase the speed of data transmission to 600MB/sec.

Currently, the newly-launched PCs and notebooks, regardless of different platforms (Intel and AMD), are all compatible with SATA3 specifications. Now it is no longer a dream to equip your computers with a main storage device whose data transmission speed is above 500MB/sec, not to mention the affordable prices for medium and small size companies and work stations.

List of SSD Prodocts:

Vendor Model Storage The vendor of SSD controller IC Power Consumption The vendor of Nand Flash Price
SATA II 64GB
Apacer Apacer Turbo AS602 60GB SandForce SF-1222 Active:390mA(Max)
Idle:135mA
Hynix (Intel) 34nm USD150
Intel Intel SSDSA2CW080G3 80GB SandForce SF-1200 Active:150 mW
Idle:100 mW
IMFT(Intel) 25mn USD179.49
KingFast KingFast KF2501MCF 60GB SandForce SF-1222 Read:1.15W
Write:1.15W
Standby:0.85W
Intel 34nm USD122.9
Kingston SV100S2 64GB JMicron JMF618 6.4W in operation
1.0W in idle
Toshiba 32nm USD99.8
SVP100S2 64GB Toshiba T6UG1XBG 8W in operation
0.05W in idle
Toshiba 32nm USD132
SNVP325S2 64GB Toshiba  3.5 W- 4.2 W in operation
0.065 W-0.075 W in idle
Toshiba USD164.99
Mach Xtreme  MX MXSSD2SDS-60G(SLC) 60GB SandForce SF-1222 Active up to 2.3W
Passive 0.5W
Samsung 50nm USD750
Patriot PATRIOT INFERNO PI60GS25SSD 60GB SandForce SF-1222 < 7.5W Intel 34nm USD233
Richmax/
SUPERSSPEED
Seraphim MLC 60GB 60GB Sandforce SF-1222TA3-SBH Idle:150mA(149.1mA)
Active:350mA
Intel 34nm USD119
SOLIDATA SOLIDATA K5(SLC) 64GB Indilinx barefoot Read:1.5W
Write:1W
Standby:0.5W
Micron 34nm USD230
Strontium Strontium SRSSDGM-25 60GB SandForce SF-1222 2250mW Micron 34nm USD123.5
Transcend Transcend TS64GSSD25S-M 64GB SMI2250 Read/Write/Idle (mA)
426 / 500 / 157
Samsung 35nm USD172.7
SATA II 128GB
Apacer Apacer Turbo AS602 120GB SandForce SF-1222 Active:390mA(Max)
Idle:135mA
Hynix (Intel) 34nm USD330
G.Skill G.SKILL PHOENIX EVO FM-25S2-115GBPE 115GB SandForce SF-1200 2.25W in operation
0.5W in idle
Micron 25nm USD209.99
G.SKILL PHOENIX PRO FM-25S2S-120GBP2 120GB SandForce SF-1200 2W in operation
0.5W in idle
Micron 34nm USD229.99
Intel Intel SSDSA2CW120G3 120GB SandForce SF-1200 Active:150 mW
Idle:100 mW 
IMFT(Intel) 25mn USD250
KingFast KingFast KF2501MCF 120GB SandForce SF-1222 Read:1.15W
Write:1.15W
Standby:0.85W
Intel 34nm USD215.2
Kingston SV100S2 128GB JMicron JMF618 6.4W in operation
1.0W in idle
Toshiba 32nm USD198
SVP100S2 128GB Toshiba T6UG1XBG 8W in operation
0.05W in idle
Toshiba 32nm USD153
Netac Netac S600 120GB SandForce SF-1200 Read:330 mA
Write:340 mA
Idle:140 mA
Intel 34nm USD259
Netcom Netcom FORESEE 128GB SMI2250 Read:200mA
Write:400mA
Standby:150mA
Intel 25nm USD215.4
Phison PS3105-S5 120GB Phison PS3105-S5 Read:200mA
Write:900mA
Idle:35mA
Toshiba 34nm USD220
PS3105-S5 128GB Phison PS3105-S5 Read:200mA
Write:900mA
Idle:35mA
Toshiba 34nm USD220
Richmax/
SUPERSSPEED
Seraphim MLC120GB 120GB Sandforce SF-1222TA3-SBH Active:420mA
Idle:150mA(141.2mA)
Intel 34nm USD 219
Seraphim MLC 240GB 240G Sandforce SF-1222TA3-SBH Active:450mA
Idle:160mA(154.5mA)
Intel 34nm USD 449
SOLIDATA SOLIDATA K8 128GB SandForce SF-1222 Read:1.5W
Write:1W 
Standby:0.5
Micron 25nm USD200
Strontium Strontium SRSSDGM-25 115GB SandForce SF-1222 2250mW Micron 25nm USD201
Transcend Transcend TS128GSSD25S-M 128GB SMI2250 Read/Write/Idle (mA)
429 / 692 / 157
Samsung 35nm USD332.7
Wintec Wintec SSD  120GB Initio   Intel 34nm USD250
SATA III
ADATA ADATA SSD S711 100GB SandForce SF-2582 Read:633mA
Write:956mA
Idle:528mA
Standby:0.3mA
Micron 25nm USD620~650
Micron/ Crucial Crucial m4 CT064M4SSD2 64GB Marvell Active:150 mW
<65 mW in idle
Micron 25nm USD163
Crucial m4 CT128M4SSD2 128GB Marvell Active:150 mW
<85 mW in idle
Micron 25nm USD300
Intel Intel SSDSC2MH250A2 250G Marvell 88SS9174-BKK2 Active:380 mW
Idle:100 mW
Intel 34nm USD599.99
OCZ OCZ Vertex3 PCBA0636-P 240G SandForce2281 2W in operation
5W in standby
IMFT(Intel/Micron)25nm USD463.3
OCZ Vertex3 PRO 200G SandForce2682 2W in operation
5W in standby
IMFT(Intel/Micron)25nm  
Plextor Plextor M2S PLUS 256G Marvell Active:0.75W
Idle:0.25W                
Micron 34nm USD700
Strontium Strontium SRSSDMX-25 128GB Marvell 2750 mW Micron 25nm USD260


About The Storage Amounts of SSDs


The prices of 60-64GB SSDs have declined to $100-150; even the 64GB SSD, which is the cheapest among all the SSDs we test out, outperforms traditional hard-disks in terms of reading efficiency. Such an outperformance is attributed to the advantage its structure. With the pursuit of bigger storage amount, the storage amounts of traditional hard-disks have increased to 1 to 2TB.


About DRAMeXchange

DRAMeXchange is a global primary provider of future intelligences, in-depth analysis reports and advisory services on DRAM and Flash memory industry with coverage including current business, spot trading prices, and market trends, capital spending and wafer capacity trends, the impact of DRAM/flash memory products on the market, and other relevant PC industry information.

© DRAMeXchange ® Tech.Inc. All rights reserved.