DRAMeXchange : Weekly Research : 【Performance Test】

【Performance Test】DRAMeXchange 2011 SSD Performance - SATA2 60GB~80GB


Published 2011-07-13 (GMT+8)


 

60~80GB SSD

DRAMeXchange: Annual Review of SSDs

In this year's annual review of SSDs by DRAMeXchange, a research division of Trendforce, we tested out 32 different 2.5-inch SSDs, including standard SSDs in the affordable price range and high-speed SDDs, which are generally adopted by medium and small size companies and work stations. We reviewed several categories of SSDs (SATA2 with 60GB and 100GB storage and SATA3 with over 100GB storage).
List of 60~80GB SSD Products:

Vendor Model Storage The vendor of SSD controller IC Power Consumption The vendor of Nand Flash Price
SATA II 64GB
Apacer Apacer Turbo AS602 60GB SandForce SF-1222 Active:390mA(Max)
Idle:135mA
Hynix (Intel) 34nm USD150
Intel Intel SSDSA2CW080G3 80GB SandForce SF-1200 Active:150 mW
Idle:100 mW
IMFT(Intel) 25mn USD179.49
KingFast KingFast KF2501MCF 60GB SandForce SF-1222 Read:1.15W
Write:1.15W
Standby:0.85W
Intel 34nm USD122.9
Kingston SV100S2 64GB JMicron JMF618 6.4W in operation
1.0W in idle
Toshiba 32nm USD99.8
SVP100S2 64GB Toshiba T6UG1XBG 8W in operation
0.05W in idle
Toshiba 32nm USD132
SNVP325S2 64GB Toshiba  3.5 W- 4.2 W in operation
0.065 W-0.075 W in idle
Toshiba USD164.99
Mach Xtreme  MX MXSSD2SDS-60G(SLC) 60GB SandForce SF-1222 Active up to 2.3W
Passive 0.5W
Samsung 50nm USD750
Patriot PATRIOT INFERNO PI60GS25SSD 60GB SandForce SF-1222 < 7.5W Intel 34nm USD233
Richmax/
SUPERSSPEED
Seraphim MLC 60GB 60GB Sandforce SF-1222TA3-SBH Idle:150mA(149.1mA)
Active:350mA
Intel 34nm USD119
SOLIDATA SOLIDATA K5(SLC) 64GB Indilinx barefoot Read:1.5W
Write:1W
Standby:0.5W
Micron 34nm USD230
Strontium Strontium SRSSDGM-25 60GB SandForce SF-1222 2250mW Micron 34nm USD123.5
Transcend Transcend TS64GSSD25S-M 64GB SMI2250 Read/Write/Idle (mA)
426 / 500 / 157
Samsung 35nm USD172.7

AS SSD Benchmark 1.6.4013.39530

The new program for measuring SSD performance is AS SSD Benchmark. This test clearly demonstrates the performance of SSDs under various application environments. We observed the benchmark during many runs, monitored and analyzed the results, and found its performance to be rather outstanding.
Of these sets, only 2 SSDs come with SLC NAND Flash: MX MXSSD2SDS-60G(SLC) and SOLIDATA K5(SLC), and both scored high in the AS SSD read benchmark. MX MXSSD2SDS-60G(SLC)'s Sandforce control chip is more powerful than SOLIDATA K5(SLC)'s Indilinx barefoot chip, but as the former comes at a much higher price, it would be better for server or workstation use.
Which one of these sets came out with the best read performance?
The answer is Intel SSDSA2CW080G3. It had the best read benchmark in this test, but KingFast KF2501MCF and Richmax/ SUPERSSPEED Seraphim MLC 60GB are the champions of overall benchmark scores.

CrystalDiskMark 3.0.1

The PATRIOT INFERNO PI60GS25SSD_60GB, MX MXSSD2SDS-60G_60GB(SLC), and Apacer Turbo AS602_60GB come close to the SATA2 transfer rate limitation, at around 280MB/s.

The gap in sequential write performance is attributed to the difference between MLC and SLC SSD models, computing power of SSD controllers, and quality and speed of NAND Flash chips. Intel SSDSA2CW080G3_80GB had good read results, but ran badly in the sequential write test. It uses the SandForce SF-1200 chip, which does not have as fast of a write performance as the SF-1222 chip.

The differences between the top five 60GB~80GB SSD sets in this benchmark, which all use the SandForce SF-1222 chip, are NAND Flash chip source and product price.

HDTune Pro v4.60

The average benchmark of HD Tune Pro read and write shows the average computing power of each SSD in daily heavy-access tasks. It combines high and low read/write performance.

Here comes the winner: KingFast KF2501MCF_60GB(MLC) and SOLIDATA K5_64GB(SLC).

IOMeter V1.1.0rc

This test clearly indicates each SSD's controller IC computing power, speed, and NAND Flash quality.
The leading SSDs use the SandForce series chip, and the Richmax/ SUPERSSPEED Seraphim MLC 60GB is the winner in the IOMeter group.

The 64GB category is the acceptable price range for general consumers. Of the 12 SSDs reviewed in this evaluation, we selected those which excel in overall performance, specifications, and quality. The recommended products are as follows:

The Best SSD of SATA2 60GB MLC

In terms of overall performance, the winner is the KingFast KF2501MCF.
The runners-up are as follows, in descending order:

Richmax/ SUPERSSPEED Seraphim MLC 60GB

Apacer Turbo AS602

PATRIOT INFERNO PI60GS25SSD

Intel SSDSA2CW080G3 (320 Series 80GB)

Strontium SRSSDGM-25

The Best SSD of SATA2 60GB SLC

The winner is the MX MXSSD2SDS-60G(SLC).

The Best Price/performance ratio SSD of SATA2 60GB

The winner is the Richmax/ SUPERSSPEED Seraphim MLC 60GB.


About DRAMeXchange

DRAMeXchange is a global primary provider of future intelligences, in-depth analysis reports and advisory services on DRAM and Flash memory industry with coverage including current business, spot trading prices, and market trends, capital spending and wafer capacity trends, the impact of DRAM/flash memory products on the market, and other relevant PC industry information.

© DRAMeXchange ® Tech.Inc. All rights reserved.